Apparently we're supposed to be able to get Shark Teeth from chests, Crocosaurus, Mondo Shark and the Pirate Galleon. I've found a few of these in chests, and when I click on Crocosaurus it does come up as one of the items you can get by defeating him/her (I've defeated it numerous times and never got a Shark Tooth - but that's a separate issue). When I click on the Mondo Shark and Pirate Galleon on the Western Map Shark Teeth isn't one of the items listed that you can get from them. Should it be? Or are there more sharks and galleon's lurking somewhere undiscovered on my Eastern Map?
Thanks for the statistic. I haven't taken it out anywhere near that number of times. I'd estimate I've killed it 10 times. I seem to get 30k grog, some EP and 2 gems more often than not. The other times I got crocodile tears.
There is a Mondo Shark on the Eastern Map that is a more reliable drop for Shark's teeth. PM me if you want the coordinates (or pop over and have a chat )
Thanks for sending the coordinates to me via DM @Ian I just uncovered one of those tiles and found a shark lurking there. Now sailing back to see if I can collect some shark teeth.