I was attacked today. The defense log said I was 72% deserted and lost over 200k gold and grog in total. But from the replay, that dude only took out 38% of my island and I only lost 60k. I am confused with what indeed happened. I indeed lost that 200k and my ranking was lowered... Hope some one could help me out.
There is currently a bug that is reporting incorrect loot values. We're in the process of fixing it right now.