How to evaluate Guild Members?

As the leader of a guild, Im trying to come up with a good way to evaluate crew members. I cant tell if their builders are busy, I cant tell if they back the perks. I feel like I'm handcuffed in trying to keep the good members and kicking the inactives/freeloaders Any help would be appreciated

 

My Captain is likely a ghost but I've been wondering the same thing.

 

I'm pretty sure @Chris [Midoki] said that in the future you would be able to see how much a person had funded.

 

My guild Kicks The Lowest 2 People EveryDay

 

Good

 

any hint on other "guild improvements" Chris?

 

Yes
And I Know One Of Them Is Troop Donations

 

ha ha, awesome (not a word I use often). now we're talking guild goodness. those of us coming from the "other" games will know the value of this...

 

Good Job Chris But how will troop donation work? will they defense against attackers? I hope not cause its hard to plunder as it is

 

fair call Chris. we'll go ahead and speculate on our own until you put us out of our misery
what ever it is I'm sure it'll be good. all has been so far. keep up the good work...

 

oh btw two thumbs up for donated troops. just saying...

 

Definitely Thumbs Up For That

 

You guys want troops to defend your island? like in CoC? I think that will be to hard.. at least for me who attack much.

 

defend and attack. why just one when both is pretty standard functionality...

 

I got an idea how about they can only be used in attacking and exploring

 

I personally think that you will just be able to donate to your current tavern limit. So donating will make your ''building time'' faster.

 

In exploring you have a mini ship behind you
In attacking there's add a ship which is the donated troops

 

I like the attacking option. boom, drop the second boat of troops to give a push to your attack.